| CAA Player of the Year | ||
| Ricardo Capilla | 1998 | |
| Matthew Delicate | 2003 | |
| Dominic Oduro | 2004 | |
| CAA Coach of the Year | ||
| Tim O'Sullivan | 1998 | |
| Tim O'Sullivan | 2002 | |
| CAA Defender of the Year | ||
| Erwan LeCrom | 1998 | |
| Emmanuel Tetiot | 1999 | |
| Milorad Djordevic | 2001 | |
| Gonzalo Segares | 2002 | |
| Gonzalo Segares | 2004 | |
| CAA Rookie of the Year | ||
| Ricardo Capilla | 1997 | |
| 1995 | ||
| Kwaku Adu-Gyamfi | first team | |
| Jim Larkin | second team | |
| 1996 | ||
| Jim Larkin | first team | |
| Carsten Feuerpfiel | second team | |
| Mervyn Wright | second team | |
| 1997 | ||
| Jim Larkin | first team | |
| Erwan LeCrom | first team | |
| Ricardo Capilla | second team | |
| John Moffatt | second team | |
| Trevor Spencer | second team | |
| 1998 | ||
| Ricardo Capilla | first team | |
| Kevin Jeffrey | first team | |
| Erwan LeCrom | first team | |
| 1999 | ||
| Gilberto Bejarano | first team | |
| Ricardo Capilla | first team | |
| Erwan LeCrom | first team | |
| 2000 | ||
| Roman Otten | second team | |
| 2001 | ||
| Milorad Djordevic | first team | |
| Roman Otten | first team | |
| Randy Ugarte | first team | |
| Gilberto Bejarano | second team | |
| Matthew Delicate | second team | |
| Gregory Premel | second team | |
| 2002 | ||
| Carlos Garay | first team | |
| Gonzalo Segares | first team | |
| Randy Ugarte | first team | |
| 2003 | ||
| McColm Cephas | first team | |
| Matthew Delicate | first team | |
| Gonzalo Segares | first team | |
| Cristian Neagu | second team | |
| Randy Ugarte | second team | |
| 2004 | ||
| Dominic Oduro | first team & rookie team | |
| Gonzalo Segares | first team | |
| Simon Toselli | first team | |
| Saul Montero | second team | |
| Ricardo Opoku | second team & rookie team | |
| Veit Schaidinger | second team | |
| Samuel Asante | rookie team | |
| 2005 | ||
| Veit Schaidinger | first team | |
| Stephen Shirely | first team | |
| Matthijs Maruanaya | second team & rookie team | |
| Andrew Dykstra | rookie team | |
| 2006 | ||
| Matthijs Maruanaya | second team | |
| Gerson Dos Santos | second team & rookie team | |
| Thomas Weingartner | rookie team | |
| 2007 | ||
| Gerson Dos Santos | first team | |
| Dirk Dittrich | second team | |
| Jorit Loehr | second team & rookie team | |
| Sven Meusch | second team | |
| Matthijs Maruanaya | third team | |
| Pat Viray | third team | |
| 2008 | ||
| Dirk Dittrich | first team | |
| Andrew Dykstra | second team | |
| Jorit Loehr | third team | |
| Thomas Huepper | rookie team | |
| 2009 | ||
| Carlos Picado | rookie team | |
| 2010 | ||
| C.J. Gehin-Scott | first team | |
| Lucas Paulini | first team | |
| Thomas Huepper | third team | |
| Jason Johnson | third team & rookie team | |
| Romena Bowie | rookie team | |
| 2011 | ||
| Juan Monge Solano | first team & rookie team | |
| Jason Johnson | second team | |
| Total | 70 | |
| first team | 29 | |
| second team | 23 | |
| third team | 5 | |
| rookie team | 13 |
