| 1995 | Harrisonburg, Va. | |
| #2 James Madison def. #7 VCU, 2-1 | Quarterfinals | |
| 1996 | Wilmington, N.C. | |
| #3 Richmond def. #6 VCU, 1-0 | Quarterfinals | |
| 1997 | Washington, D.C. | |
| #3 VCU def. #6 James Madison, 1-0 |
Quarterfinals | |
| #3 VCU def. #2 George Mason, 2-0 | Semifinals | |
| #3 VCU tied #1 American, 2-2 (40T) | Championship | |
|
(VCU prevails on PKs 9-8) |
||
| Tournament MVP: Jim Larkin | ||
| 1998 | Virginia Beach, Va. | |
| #1 VCU def. #8 American, 4-1 | Quarterfinals | |
| #4 Richmond def. #1 VCU, 1-0 | Semifinals | |
| All-Tournament Team: Dwayne Bergeron, | ||
| Trevor Spencer | ||
| 1999 | Virginia Beach, Va. | |
| #2 VCU def. #7 East Carolina, 1-0 | Quarterfinals | |
| #2 VCU def. #3 Richmond, 4-3 (OT) | Semifinals | |
| #5 William & Mary def. #2 VCU, 4-2 | Championship | |
| All-Tournament Team: Gilberto Bejarano, | ||
| Kevin Jeffrey, Emmanuel Tetiot | ||
| 2000 | Virginia Beach, Va. | |
| #5 VCU def. #4 George Mason, 1-0 | First Round | |
| #1 James Madison def. #5 VCU, 3-0 | Semifinals | |
| All-Tournament Team: Roman Otten, | ||
| Rodolfo Pacheco | ||
| 2001 | Virginia Beach, Va. | |
| #4 VCU tied #5 George Mason, 0-0
(2ot) |
First Round |
|
| (VCU prevails on PKs 4-2) | ||
| #4 VCU def. #1 Old Dominion, 1-0
(4ot) |
Semifinals | |
| #2 James Madison def. #4 VCU, 1-0 |
Championship | |
| All-Tournament Team:
Gilberto Bejarano, |
||
| Milorad Djordevic, Roman Otten |
||
| 2002 | Virginia Beach, Va. |
|
| #1 VCU def. Towson, 4-0 |
Semifinals | |
| #1 VCU def. #2 William & Mary,
2-1 |
Championship | |
| Tournament MVP: Matthew
Delicate |
||
| All-Tournament Team:
Matthew Delicate, |
||
| Carlos Garay, Matt Pauls, Gonzalo
Segares |
||
| 2003 | Richmond, Va. | |
| #1 VCU def. #4 James Madison, 3-0 | Semifinals | |
| #1 VCU def. George Mason, 2-0 | Championship | |
| Tournament MVP: Matthew Delicate | ||
| All-Tournament Team: McColm Cephas, | ||
| Matthew Delicate, Saul Montero, | ||
| Christian Neagu | ||
| 2004 | Richmond, Va. | |
| #5 Hofstra def. #1 VCU, 1-0 | Semifinals | |
| All-Tournament Team: Helmis Matute, | ||
| Gonzalo Segares | ||
| 2005 | Norfolk, Va. | |
| #5 UNC Wilmington def. #4 VCU, 2-0 | First Round | |
| 2006 | Virginia Beach, Va. | |
| Did not qualify | ||
| 2007 | Virginia Beach, Va. | |
| #3 VCU def. #6 Northeastern, 3-1 | First Round | |
| #2 Old Dominion def. #3 VCU, 2-1 | Semifinals | |
| All-Tournament Team: Owusu Sekyere, | ||
| Gerson dos Santos | ||
| 2008 | Wilmington, N.C. | |
| Did not qualify | ||
| 2009 | Wilmington, N.C. | |
| Did not qualify | ||
| 2010 | Williamsburg, Va. | |
| #3 Hofstra def. #2 VCU, 2-1 | Semifinals | |
| All-Tournament Team: Alberto Fonseca | ||
| Lucas Paulini |
